Mystery shopping for charities

Mystery shopping for charities

This page is for charities of any size. Supporters meet you in many places: the website, a call to the office, a charity shop, a volunteer enquiry or a request for information about your service. We send a trained shopper with a realistic scenario to one or more of these. You then see what it feels like to deal with your charity, beyond the fundraising ask itself.

Ask for prices  Get a free report  See an example report

A simple illustration of a welcoming charity shop front with a window display, a donation bag at the door and a volunteer badge on the counter.

Why every contact is part of your reputation

People give time, goods and money to charities because they believe in the cause. They also expect to be thanked and treated with care.

A donor who rings with a question may be a supporter of many years. A volunteer enquiry may come from a student with a free afternoon each week. A person visiting a shop may be there for a bargain, not the cause.

Each of them forms a view of you from small things: a call returned, a clear email, a welcome at the door.

Charities often run on small teams and shared inboxes. Staff and volunteers care deeply, but they are stretched. Problems are rarely about attitude. They are about systems and time.

A mystery shop shows you the experience as a newcomer meets it. You can then protect what is working and mend what is not.

That is useful for trustees as well as for managers.

Three doors into your charity

We choose the door or doors that matter most to you. Each uses a short, realistic scenario.

As a donor, the shopper asks a question about giving, such as how a gift is used or how to change a regular gift. They note how the question is handled and how they are thanked.

As a volunteer, the shopper sends an enquiry and notes how quickly it is answered. They see what information they receive and whether there is a clear next step.

As a shop customer, they visit a charity shop. They notice the welcome, the layout and the till. They may ask about donating goods or about Gift Aid.

As a person seeking information about your service, they ask how to find out what help is available. Shoppers never pretend to be in crisis, and we never create a safeguarding situation. These checks are about enquiry handling only.

Warmth, clarity and follow-through

We use the same ten checks as for any business, shaped to your setting.

Website experience and ease of making contact: can a supporter find how to give, volunteer or ask for help in a few clicks? Response time and telephone manner: how long does a message wait, and how is a call answered?

Customer welcome and understanding the need: does your team find out why this person is here before explaining anything? Explanation of the service: are the cause, the gift and the role described in plain words?

Trust and professionalism: is the person treated with respect, and are their details handled with care? Attempt to secure support: is there a clear invitation to give, join or sign up? Follow-up: is there a thank-you, and does it come quickly?

For charities we add a few more. How is thanks shown? How are contact preferences explained? How is a volunteer welcomed in the first week?

Questions you may want to ask yourself

Use these as prompts for your own charity.

Does an enquiry to the general inbox get a reply from a named team within a set number of days? Is that promise written anywhere?

Does a donor's thank-you arrive, and does it say what the gift will do? Is the tone warm without being over the top?

Can a volunteer see what the first week involves? Is there someone to ask? Many keen people drift away when nothing happens after the first email.

In the shop, is the front window welcoming? Is donating goods easy to understand? Does the till explain Gift Aid clearly and without pressure?

Do the website, the shop and the office all say the same thing about what you do?

Is there a clear way to ask how a service works, with a phone number or form that is answered?

These are matters of process and time. They are not a reflection on anyone who gives their effort to your cause.

What you receive

You receive a report with scores for each part of the journey we tested. Each one has an observation beside it.

Trustees, a chief executive and a volunteer manager can all read it. We write it in plain language, with no sector jargon.

It lists strengths first, so that your team sees what is going well. Weaknesses follow with evidence. Then comes an action plan in priority order.

Every report is checked by hand before release. We never name or rank staff or volunteers, and we make no covert recordings. Findings describe one customer journey on one occasion, so please use them as a prompt for improvement, not a verdict.

After you have made changes, a retest can measure progress. Some teams choose to repeat the shop after a busy season, so that results can be compared across the year.

Your report is written for your team to read, not for anyone outside it.

Who this suits and how to start

This suits local charities with a shop and a small team, and national charities with many points of contact. It also suits community groups that rely on volunteers.

We ask you to confirm that staff and volunteers know in general terms that mystery shopping may take place. They do not need to know when.

Email us to ask for the details and a quotation. We can also send a free first-impression report on your public website and donation pages, seen as a first-time visitor would see them.

The Custom Questions option lets you write 10, 20 or 30 questions on the points that worry you most, and choose how many shoppers to use.

If you have a separate fundraising team and want the ask itself checked, see our fundraising page. It looks at street, doorstep, telephone and mail asks.

Case studies

Example case study

Volunteers who never heard back

A small animal rescue charity with one shop and a part-time office

The challenge

The charity wanted more regular volunteers for its shop. Several people had made contact, but few had turned up. The manager wondered what happened between the first message and the first shift. She asked for a shop of both the enquiry and the shop floor.

What we found

The volunteer enquiry through the website was answered after six days. The reply was kind but did not say what a first shift involved or who to ask for. No follow-up arrived. In the shop, the welcome was warm, though the donation bags were hard to find and the till did not mention Gift Aid.

The result

The charity set a three-day target for replies, wrote a short welcome note with the shift details and put a clear donation sign at the door. A retest found a reply in two days and a welcome note that named a contact.

Example case study

Different answers from different places

A medium-sized charity supporting young people, with an office, a website and a volunteer programme

The challenge

Supporters had said that it was hard to know how to get involved. The charity wanted to see whether the website, the office phone and the enquiry inbox told the same story. They asked for a clear picture of the routes a new supporter might take.

What we found

The website gave one telephone number and the contact page gave another. The office phone was answered clearly, but the caller was passed to a second team without being told why. The inbox reply was thoughtful, though it described the volunteer programme differently from the website.

The result

The charity listed one telephone number across all pages and gave the team a short note on how to describe the volunteer programme. It also added a line to its transfer script. The retest found matching information on each route. The communications lead agreed to review the pages each quarter.

Example case studies are illustrations of the kind of findings and changes a check can lead to. They do not describe a named client.

Frequently asked questions

Can you test our charity shops?

Yes. A shopper visits as an ordinary customer. They note the welcome, the window, the layout, the till and how Gift Aid is explained. They may also ask about donating goods. Reports are about the process and the team as a whole, never about named volunteers.

Will shoppers pretend to need our service?

Only in a limited, service-only way. A shopper may ask how to find out what help is available, or how to refer someone. They never pretend to be in crisis, and we never create a safeguarding situation. The check is about how clearly the enquiry is handled.

Do our volunteers need to be told?

We ask you to confirm that staff and volunteers have been told in general terms that mystery shopping may take place. They do not need to know the date. We never name or rank individuals, so the findings can be shared and used for training.

How is this different from your fundraising page?

The fundraising service checks the ask itself: street, doorstep, telephone and mail. This page covers everything around it, such as donor care, shops, volunteer enquiries and how people find information about your service. Some charities use both, one after the other.

Can you check our phone line or enquiry inbox?

Yes. The shopper makes a short, realistic enquiry and notes how long a reply takes, how it sounds and whether the next step is clear. We never use real personal details or pose as someone in distress. The result is a record of what a newcomer would find.

Does this work for very small charities?

Yes. A small charity can choose one door, such as the volunteer enquiry or the shop, and test only that. The Custom Questions option lets you decide what to ask and how many shoppers to use. Small teams often gain a lot from one clear outside view.

Next step

See how customers really experience your business.

Ask for prices, or start with a free first-impression report of your website.

Ask for prices  Free report

Other sectors