Mystery shopping for councils

Mystery shopping for local government

This page is for councils, from county and unitary to district, borough and town. We act as an ordinary resident with an everyday enquiry. We try your phone line, your website and, where it suits, your front desk. Then we compare what happened with the service standards you have published. You receive scores, evidence and a short list of what to fix first.

Ask for prices  Get a free report  See an example report

A simple illustration of a town hall with a speech bubble, a telephone and a laptop beside it, joined by a dotted line.

Residents cannot take their custom elsewhere

A person unhappy with a shop can walk to another shop. A resident who needs the council usually cannot. They need a bin collected, a form processed or a road mended. The council is the only place to ask.

That makes first contact important. A clear answer saves a second call. A vague answer often turns into a complaint. It may become an email to a councillor or a post on a local community page.

Councils also make public promises. Many publish service standards for how fast calls are answered and enquiries are replied to. Residents read those promises, and some quote them back.

Contact centre staff deal with a huge range of subjects in one day. Good systems help them as much as good training does.

Residents fund these services through local taxes, so they expect a clear answer and a fair hearing. A good first reply also cuts repeat contacts, which frees staff time for harder cases.

We help you see whether daily practice matches what is written down.

Following one resident enquiry from start to finish

Each check starts with a simple scenario agreed with you. It might be a missed bin collection, a bulky waste booking, a parking permit question or a pothole report. We avoid anything sensitive, such as benefits, social care or child protection.

The shopper first looks on your website. Can they find the right page? Is there an online form, and does it work on a phone?

Next they try another route. That could be the telephone line, an email or webchat. They note the wait, how the call is answered and whether they are told what happens next. The shopper writes notes straight after each contact, while the details are fresh.

Where it suits, they visit a customer service point or library hub. They ask the same question and see whether the answer matches. Afterwards we record whether the resident hears back, and when. We note the time of every step, so you can see exactly where a resident waited.

What we measure against your own standards

We start with the standards you have published. If you promise that calls are answered within a set time, we time them. If you promise a reply to emails within a number of working days, we track that too.

We then score the universal checks. These cover website experience, ease of making contact, response time and telephone manner. They also cover welcome, understanding of the enquiry, clear explanation, trust and professionalism, and follow-up.

For councils we add local checks. Is the right team named? Is a reference number given? Is the resident told plainly when nothing can be promised?

Is the language everyday English or council jargon?

We also look at access. Is there an easy-read option? Can a deaf or hard of hearing resident find a way to get in touch? We record what is offered and how easy it is to find.

Councils rarely sell anything, so the check on securing the sale changes. We ask a different question: does the resident leave knowing exactly what happens next?

Things worth checking in your own service

These are prompts, not accusations. Every council is different, and one shop shows one occasion only.

Check whether the web page and the telephone menu give the same answer. Check whether a call is passed between teams without anyone saying why. Check whether a resident has to repeat their address three times.

Look at the online form. Does it confirm that it was sent? Does anyone reply? A form that sits in a shared inbox is hard to spot from the inside.

Look at what happens when the first person cannot answer. Does the resident get a named team, a direct number or a call-back? Or are they sent back to the start?

Look at call-back promises and out-of-hours messages. Are they kept?

Look at the date a page was last updated, and whether links to documents still work. Finally, check that help for residents who cannot use the internet is easy to find.

What the council receives

You receive a scored report. Each score is backed by an observation, such as a call time, a page name or a reference number. We use notes and screenshots. We never make covert recordings.

The report lists strengths, weaknesses and a prioritised action plan. The plan separates quick fixes from bigger changes. A wrong web page is a quick fix. How enquiries move between teams is a bigger change.

Evidence sits beside each score, so a service head can check the facts. Where something worked well, we say so, because staff should know what to keep doing.

A short summary page is written so that it can be shared with service heads, scrutiny groups or members.

We never name or rank individual staff. There are no league tables. Findings show one customer journey on one occasion, and they are a prompt for improvement, not a verdict.

A retest later measures whether the changes helped.

Who it suits and how to start

This suits customer services managers, heads of service, digital teams and anyone preparing for a service review. Parish and town councils can use a smaller check on one or two services.

We ask you to confirm that staff have been told, in general terms, that mystery shopping may take place. They do not need to know when.

You can ask for a free first-impression report on one route to see how we work. Your phone line is a popular choice.

Most councils begin with a small check on one service and widen it after reading the report. A retest can follow a staff briefing or a website change.

To test one particular service, try Custom Questions. You write up to 10, 20 or 30 of your own questions and choose how many shoppers to use. Email us and we will send you a quotation.

Case studies

Example case study

A missed-collection report that went nowhere

A district council covering several market towns

The challenge

The council had published a standard that missed-collection reports would be answered within two working days. Complaints about bins were still rising. Managers wanted to know where the process was slipping, and whether web reports and phone reports were treated the same way.

What we found

Our shopper reported a missed collection through the website form. The form gave no confirmation message and no reference number. A call to the contact line took eleven minutes to answer, and the adviser could not see the web report. No reply arrived by the end of the fourth working day. The web page also promised a call-back, which never came.

The result

The council added a confirmation screen with a reference number and gave advisers sight of web reports. A retest six weeks later found calls answered in under four minutes and a reply within two working days.

Example case study

Two routes, two different answers

A town council running a small office, a community hall and a market

The challenge

The clerk suspected that hall booking information on the website was out of date, but had no time to test the full enquiry route as a member of the public would. The clerk asked us to look at the web page, the telephone line and the email address together.

What we found

The website listed the hall as available on weekday evenings. The telephone answer service said weekday bookings needed written approval, which the site never mentioned. An email enquiry was answered after six days. Opening hours differed on two pages.

The result

The clerk rewrote the hall page, set up an email auto-reply that gave a reply date, and agreed a simple call-back routine. The follow-up check showed matching answers on the web, phone and email. It was also easier to see who to contact about a different booking question.

Example case studies are illustrations of the kind of findings and changes a check can lead to. They do not describe a named client.

Frequently asked questions

Do you check us against our own published service standards?

Yes, where you have them. If your council promises to answer calls or reply to emails within a set time, we measure that on the day of the check. We also score the wider experience, such as clarity and follow-up. The report shows where practice matched your promise and where it did not.

Will you test sensitive services such as social care or benefits?

No. We keep to everyday enquiries, such as bins, parking, roads, planning questions and general information. We never involve safeguarding, social care or personal benefit claims. Shoppers do not share real personal data, and the scenario is agreed with you in writing before anything starts.

Can the check cover phone, web and in person?

Yes. Most councils begin with one or two routes, such as the contact centre and a web form. We can add a visit to a customer service point or library hub. Using the same question on each route shows whether people get the same answer everywhere.

Will individual officers be named in the report?

No. We never name or rank individual staff. Findings are written about processes, scripts, training and systems. We ask you to confirm that staff have been told, in general terms, that mystery shopping may take place, so nobody is caught by surprise.

Is one mystery shop enough to judge a service?

One shop shows one customer journey on one occasion, so we treat it as a prompt for improvement, not a verdict. A single check can point to things worth looking at. A retest, or several shoppers using Custom Questions, shows whether a pattern is real.

Can we write our own questions?

Yes. With the Custom Questions option you write up to 10, 20 or 30 questions about the things your council cares about, such as how a particular team handles call-backs. You also choose how many shoppers are used. We can help you word the questions clearly.

Next step

See how customers really experience your business.

Ask for prices, or start with a free first-impression report of your website.

Ask for prices  Free report

Other sectors